Otter: No, I think we have to go all out. I think that this situation absolutely requires a really futile and stupid gesture be done on somebody's part.
Bluto: We're just the guys to do it.- National Lampoon's Animal House, 1978.
Earth hour came and went. I did nothing out of the ordinary. I was not an assclown in that I did not turn on extra lights like I heard some people were planning.
Ottawa Hydro reported a 4% drop in electricity usage for Earth Hour! That's 4% of 1/24 of 1/365 of a year's worth of electricity. In other words 4.6 one-millionths of the city's annual power usage. Let me write that out for you: 0.0000046 times the annual electricity usage. If you were a millionaire and saved that percentage in a year, it would be $4.60. It is, for all practical purposes, nothing... ZERO. So let's drop any pretense that Earth Hour made any energy savings of value.
But, my critics say, the purpose of Earth Hour was to raise AWARENESS. Ok, let's explore that. What did anyone learn, awareness wise, that they didn't know last Friday? Did anyone really not know that turning off lights saves electricity? More to the point, how many people now feel that they've done their deed for the year - they've helped save 4% of an hour's electricity! So today they climbed into their Chrysler Le Behemoth and used 5 gallons of gas driving in from Barrhaven to work, and they're not even going to think about this stuff until Earth Hour next year.
Certainly, nobody was educated in the productive things that can be done to save energy or the environment. Let's face the cruel, hard fact: Western civilization cannot live in the dark without lights or electricity, so turning off lights for an hour is a completely meaningless gesture. Realistically, nobody is going to turn back the clock to a time of oil lanterns and huddling around the fireplace, and Earth Hour promoters never did offer any real AWARENESS about how to save energy in the modern world.
I, however, will offer some true awareness that will strike at the very heart of the issue. Here are Darin's hints at how people in Ottawa can make a difference and save energy without the Earth Hour bollocks:
1. Ottawa needs to deploy realistic, effective mass transit, and the citizens of Ottawa need to use it. "Throw on more buses" is NOT the answer for a battery of reasons, but climate and congestion are two of them. Like it or not, taxes will have to be raised to pay for this. If we don't suck it up now, we'll be telling our kids to suck it up later. We don't need more idiots on bicycles on icy winter roads, either. We need mass transit.
2. Related to the first point, people who live beyond the greenbelt need their taxes jacked up to cover the cost of the extension of services (like transit) to their remote locations. Sorry folks, living in suburbia puts a burden on everyone else. We need your SUVs off the road, and we need you to pay for the environmentally damaging infrastructure extensions that support your suburban paradise.
3. Denser city development. If more people lived within walking distance of work we'd not only improve the environment, we'd have less fat people too! We'd need LESS mass transit if less people needed to be transported. There'd be less road congestion, less environmental damage due to suburban development. Hell, with people actually living downtown, Ottawa might even develop some fun!
4. We need smaller families. Less new people being born means less energy consumption for all time. That means we also need social change to go with a reducing population. We can't depend on unbounded growth to sustain our social programs, for example, because we simply can't sustain the environment with an ever increasing number of consumers being squeezed out. Think of all the energy you have used / will use from birth to death. Think of all the environmental impact that you have had and will have. When you choose not to have a child, you're saving that much energy and impact, plus that much times all future descendants. Wow, talk about doing something positive for the climate, the environment, and the world! I know this is a strange thing, but if you're truly concerned about the environment, this should be a factor in your family planning decision.
Earth Hour didn't tell anyone this sort of stuff. Earth Hour just let people who aren't really interested in this stuff make a useless gesture and feel good about themselves. To me, that's a negative thing because it doesn't address the problem - in fact, it prolongs the problem.















Recent Comments